Chuck Schumer Is Yesterday’s Man




Politics


/
November 16, 2026

The Senate Democratic chief simply retains exhibiting why he must be changed.

Edit

Senate minority leader Chuck Schumer (D-NY) speaks at a press conference with other members of the Senate Democratic caucus following a policy luncheon at the US Capitol in Washington, DC, on November 10, 2026.
Senate minority chief Chuck Schumer (D-NY) speaks at a press convention with different members of the Senate Democratic caucus following a coverage luncheon on the US Capitol in Washington, DC, on November 10, 2026.(Nathan Posner / Anadolu by way of Getty Photographs)

If you wish to smash a boisterous celebration, simply hand over a microphone to Chuck Schumer. The Senate Democratic chief is the final word buzzkill, adept at deploying a droning voice that may flip giddy jubilation into existential dread.

November 3 was one of many happiest nights Democrats have recognized in a long time, because the sheer dimension of the occasion’s victory within the midterm elections turned obvious. After a decade of Trump dominating public life as standard-bearer of the Republican Celebration, right here eventually was proof that the general public, even in purple states similar to Texas and South Carolina, had been fed up. Crushed down as they had been by frustration on the GOP pushing a hard-right agenda, Democrats may lastly entertain the hopes of a greater future.

However the temporary remarks Schumer delivered that night time had been a reminder that Trump and the Republicans had been solely a part of the issue the nation faces. There’s additionally the disheartening indisputable fact that the Democrats are led by political dinosaurs who haven’t any understanding of the urgency of the present second.

Schumer is now going through a problem for the submit of Senate majority chief from Maryland’s Chris Van Hollen. Schumer’s election night time speech gives clear proof as to why Van Hollen deserves to win.

Schumer began with a query: “How did he win?” His reply: “At first, we centered on American households and their ache and their wants, their struggling. They don’t seem to be having a very good life, and they’re nervous in regards to the future for themselves and their kids.” Schumer summed up the election as being about three points: prices, chaos, and corruption.

What’s notable amongst this imprecise litany of complaints are all the problems unnoticed that produced heated debate and no scarcity of voter anger: the Iran Conflict and its position in destabilizing the world economic system, US help of Israel as an element within the battle, the rise of AI and information facilities, and the outsize roles of tech plutocrats like Elon Musk in corrupting the political system.

Present Concern

Cover of December 2026 Issue

Schumer expressed shock that the Republicans “embraced Trump” and “adopted Trump over the cliff as among the time he talked about extraneous issues that had been ridiculous however a lot of the time he carried out issues that raised their prices.” For most individuals, speaking about “extraneous issues” wouldn’t make the record of Trump’s thousand worst offenses, so it was puzzling why Schumer felt it essential to spotlight in a brief victory speech.

Schumer ended his peroration with a puzzling metaphor: “The American individuals lowered the purple brick wall to a pile of bricks.” As commentators similar to Jon Stewart and Sam Seder identified, these phrases had been extra prone to generate confusion than inspiration. What precisely is the “purple brick wall”? Additional, partitions are normally lowered to rubble, not a pile of bricks. If the bricks nonetheless exist, then the purple wall may be rebuilt.

Seder rightly famous the absurdity of Schumer’s amazement at congressional Republicans’ loyalty to Trump, provided that anybody who has been sentient for the final decade ought to have seen that Trump simply gained the GOP presidential nomination 3 times in a row and turned the occasion into his private cult. There are few information extra apparent in American public life than that the Republican Celebration is totally subservient to Trump. Nevertheless it’s a indisputable fact that Schumer nonetheless has a tough time accepting or acknowledging.

Partly, it is because Schumer is deeply dedicated to ancien régime restoration. He nonetheless appears to see Trump as a regrettable anomaly who will at some point disappear and permit these most legendary creatures, the “affordable Republicans,” to return. On this worldview, Democrats similar to Schumer must preserve signaling they’re able to work with Republicans to be able to hasten the return of regular politics. For this reason Schumer can solely discuss politics in essentially the most summary of phrases (prices, chaos, and corruption) fairly than specifying actual areas of disagreement.

Schumer has been fairly candid about this technique. In March 2025, he caved in to Republicans throughout funds negotiations, making concessions that angered his fellow Democrats. Explaining his pondering in an interview with The New York Occasions, Schumer stated his purpose was to attend until Trump’s approval rankings have dropped under 40 %:

And when he went under 40 % within the polls, the Republican legislators began working with us. He was at 51. He’s now at 48. We’re gonna preserve at it till he goes under 40. Look, I speak to numerous these Republican legislators. I’ve labored with them. A few of them are Trump devotees. However lots of them don’t like him, don’t respect him and fear about what he’s doing to our nation. Proper now he’s so widespread they will’t resist him. I imply, so lots of them got here to me and stated: “I don’t suppose Hegseth ought to be protection secretary or R.F.Okay. ought to be H.H.S. However Trump needs him. He gained.” The Republicans want to have some freedom from Trump, however they gained’t till we convey him down in recognition. That occurred with Bush in 2005. It occurred with Trump in 2017. When it occurs, I’m hopeful that our Republican colleagues will resume working with us. And I speak to them. One of many locations is within the health club. Once you’re on that bike in your shorts, panting away subsequent to a Republican, numerous the inhibitions come off.

This idea of latent Republican moderation rests on nothing greater than locker-room conviviality—hardly the idea for a significant political agenda. We are going to now have an empirical take a look at to see if Schumer’s idea is right. Trump’s approval rankings went under 40 % in April and have typically stayed nicely below that threshold. The Republicans suffered a wipeout within the midterms. But there isn’t any proof that the GOP is moderating. Within the wake of the midterm trouncing, Home Republicans picked Jim Jordan, a hard-right Trump loyalist, as their new chief. The Home held a vote to question Protection Secretary Pete Hegseth. Thomas Massie of Kentucky, who introduced the movement to the ground, was the one Republican to vote for it. That near-total GOP opposition, and the truth that 11 Democrats failed to point out up for the vote, was sufficient to kill the hassle. Massie himself had been defeated earlier this yr within the Republican main and is leaving Congress.

Like many centrists, Schumer fashions himself as a realist. In reality, he’s a fantasist whose idea of politics rests on a world that not exists, if it ever did.

Past his fetishization of bipartisanship, Schumer’s substantive political commitments are additionally out of tune with the present pressing second in politics. In an interview with The Nation, Senator Bernie Sanders listed three areas the place Schumer is out of contact: Israel/Palestine, taxing the rich, and AI. Sanders described Schumer as somebody who “a man who needs to tinker across the edges” fairly than struggle for systematic change. In different phrases, Schumer is yesterday’s man, which is motive sufficient to help Chris Van Hollen as a alternative.

Jeet Heer



Jeet Heer is a nationwide affairs correspondent for The Nation and host of the weekly Nation podcast, The Time of Monsters. He additionally pens the month-to-month column “Morbid Signs.” The writer of In Love with Artwork: Francoise Mouly’s Adventures in Comics with Artwork Spiegelman (2013) and Candy Lechery: Critiques, Essays and Profiles (2014), Heer has written for quite a few publications, together with The New Yorker, The Paris Evaluation, Virginia Quarterly Evaluation, The American Prospect, The Guardian, The New Republic, and The Boston Globe.

Extra from The Nation

Dylan Visits DC Next

Democrats Should Not Give an Inch to the Lame-Duck Congress

On this week’s Elie v. U.S., our justice correspondent makes the case for Democrats to dam Trump’s try at judiciary-stuffing. Plus, boycott Harry Potter!

Elie Mystal

Senator Chris Van Hollen (D-MD) introduces Democratic candidate for the US Senate Minnesota Lieutenant Governor Peggy Flanagan, during a volunteer appreciation event at Black Heart of Saint Paul on August 8, 2026, in St. Paul, Minnesota.

The senator netted key endorsements from progressives, activists, and unions in his quest to oust Chuck Schumer. However he nonetheless faces an uphill battle.

John Nichols

Federal agents detain someone near 19th and Portland Avenue S. in Minneapolis, Minnesota, on Thursday, January, 29, 2026.

Voters made their disgust with Trump’s battle on immigrants clear. Now, with the fanatical Stephen Miller given much more energy, Democrats should tackle the administration.

Felipe de la Hoz

Vice President JD Vance holds a knife presented him at the 2nd Marine Aircraft Wing's annual Marine Corps Birthday Ball on November 12, 2026, in New Bern, North Carolina.

A brand new report exhibits how the pair is robbing Venezuela blind on behalf of considered one of their donors.

Jeet Heer



Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top